News

Dublin school board reverses course, approves agreement with teachers' union

Trustees also identify Dan Moirao as top candidate for acting superintendent, pending final contract

The Dublin Unified School District Board of Trustees has signed off on a tentative contract agreement with the Dublin Teachers Association (DTA) for the 2020-21 school year, following a particularly tense week in the school community.

The conditions of the agreement, negotiated by the district and the DTA and ratified by the DTA in May, included a retroactive 0.5% increase on the salary schedule for the 2019-20 school year and a 3.125% increase for the 2020-21 school year. It also contained a $40 hourly rate for certificated staff and a new salary schedule for specialists, according to Diane Manske, interim assistant superintendent of human resources.

The agreement was initially denied in a 3-2 vote at the June 11 board meeting. Board President Dan Cherrier and Trustees Gabi Blackman and Catherine Kuo cited state budget uncertainty, wanting to wait until more information was available before committing to the contract.

In weeks following the initial vote, members of the DTA vocally condemned the three trustees on social media. Superintendent Dave Marken abruptly announced his resignation on June 23, prompting some community members to blame the three trustees for driving out a well-liked superintendent. Petitions with hundreds of signatures have been circulating -- one calling for Cherrier, Blackman, and Kuo to resign, and the other reaffirming community support for them.

While the vote to reconsider and then approve the tentative agreement on Tuesday evening was unanimous in light of new information about the budget, Cherrier, Blackman and Kuo took the chance to clarify why they cast their rejection votes at the June 11 meeting.

What's local journalism worth to you?

Support DanvilleSanRamon.com for as little as $5/month.

Learn more

“The path forward two weeks ago was not doable and it was high-risk,” Blackman explained. “I’d like to thank (Gov. Gavin) Newsom for actually working with the legislature to come up with a plan that works for our schools.”

She then addressed Dublin teachers, saying: “I stand by you always. We didn’t decline the tentative agreement because of anything you did, it had nothing to do with you. It merely had to do with state funding being withdrawn and putting the board in a very difficult financial situation. As a board it is our job to make sure we have healthy funding ... I’m thrilled to see that there’s better financing now.”

Trustee Amy Miller, who had voted along with Vice President Megan Rouse to approve the agreement two weeks ago, disagreed. She insisted that she and Rouse were “in no way being financially irresponsible,” and that they truly believed that they had enough information to approve the tentative agreement three weeks ago, even if the path then was less obvious.

Cherrier echoed Blackman’s sentiments, emphasizing that the board “has a responsibility to keep this district financially solvent” and reaffirming that their previous decision was not meant as a reflection of anything that staff did wrong.

Public comment on the item reflected community tension, with some comments harshly criticizing the initial vote of the three trustees and some comments commending them for “asking the tough questions” and expressing that the “smear campaign” against them was inappropriate.

Stay informed

Get daily headlines sent straight to your inbox.

Sign up

Following their approval of the agreement with the DTA, the board approved another item to extend the same salary increases and other key provisions in the agreement to all other employee groups.

In other business

* After Marken’s announcement last week, the board officially accepted his resignation during closed session in a 3-2 vote on Tuesday, with Rouse and Miller dissenting. Marken will officially retire in August; he will take time off after July 1 but will be available for consultation.

* The board reported out of closed session that the new acting superintendent will be Dan Moirao, conditional on successful negotiation of his contract. Moirao has previously served as interim assistant superintendent with the district, and Rouse noted that he is “highly qualified to help the district as we transition to the search for an interim and eventually a permanent superintendent.” He was nominated unanimously.

* The board voted 5-0 to modify the calendar by adding a regular board meeting on July 7 in order to approve Moirao’s contract and present an informational item on grade configuration at Cottonwood Creek School.

Follow DanvilleSanRamon.com on Twitter @DanvilleSanRamo, Facebook and on Instagram @ for breaking news, local events, photos, videos and more.

Dublin school board reverses course, approves agreement with teachers' union

Trustees also identify Dan Moirao as top candidate for acting superintendent, pending final contract

by / Danville San Ramon

Uploaded: Wed, Jul 1, 2020, 10:48 pm

The Dublin Unified School District Board of Trustees has signed off on a tentative contract agreement with the Dublin Teachers Association (DTA) for the 2020-21 school year, following a particularly tense week in the school community.

The conditions of the agreement, negotiated by the district and the DTA and ratified by the DTA in May, included a retroactive 0.5% increase on the salary schedule for the 2019-20 school year and a 3.125% increase for the 2020-21 school year. It also contained a $40 hourly rate for certificated staff and a new salary schedule for specialists, according to Diane Manske, interim assistant superintendent of human resources.

The agreement was initially denied in a 3-2 vote at the June 11 board meeting. Board President Dan Cherrier and Trustees Gabi Blackman and Catherine Kuo cited state budget uncertainty, wanting to wait until more information was available before committing to the contract.

In weeks following the initial vote, members of the DTA vocally condemned the three trustees on social media. Superintendent Dave Marken abruptly announced his resignation on June 23, prompting some community members to blame the three trustees for driving out a well-liked superintendent. Petitions with hundreds of signatures have been circulating -- one calling for Cherrier, Blackman, and Kuo to resign, and the other reaffirming community support for them.

While the vote to reconsider and then approve the tentative agreement on Tuesday evening was unanimous in light of new information about the budget, Cherrier, Blackman and Kuo took the chance to clarify why they cast their rejection votes at the June 11 meeting.

“The path forward two weeks ago was not doable and it was high-risk,” Blackman explained. “I’d like to thank (Gov. Gavin) Newsom for actually working with the legislature to come up with a plan that works for our schools.”

She then addressed Dublin teachers, saying: “I stand by you always. We didn’t decline the tentative agreement because of anything you did, it had nothing to do with you. It merely had to do with state funding being withdrawn and putting the board in a very difficult financial situation. As a board it is our job to make sure we have healthy funding ... I’m thrilled to see that there’s better financing now.”

Trustee Amy Miller, who had voted along with Vice President Megan Rouse to approve the agreement two weeks ago, disagreed. She insisted that she and Rouse were “in no way being financially irresponsible,” and that they truly believed that they had enough information to approve the tentative agreement three weeks ago, even if the path then was less obvious.

Cherrier echoed Blackman’s sentiments, emphasizing that the board “has a responsibility to keep this district financially solvent” and reaffirming that their previous decision was not meant as a reflection of anything that staff did wrong.

Public comment on the item reflected community tension, with some comments harshly criticizing the initial vote of the three trustees and some comments commending them for “asking the tough questions” and expressing that the “smear campaign” against them was inappropriate.

Following their approval of the agreement with the DTA, the board approved another item to extend the same salary increases and other key provisions in the agreement to all other employee groups.

In other business

* After Marken’s announcement last week, the board officially accepted his resignation during closed session in a 3-2 vote on Tuesday, with Rouse and Miller dissenting. Marken will officially retire in August; he will take time off after July 1 but will be available for consultation.

* The board reported out of closed session that the new acting superintendent will be Dan Moirao, conditional on successful negotiation of his contract. Moirao has previously served as interim assistant superintendent with the district, and Rouse noted that he is “highly qualified to help the district as we transition to the search for an interim and eventually a permanent superintendent.” He was nominated unanimously.

* The board voted 5-0 to modify the calendar by adding a regular board meeting on July 7 in order to approve Moirao’s contract and present an informational item on grade configuration at Cottonwood Creek School.

Comments

There are no comments yet. Please share yours below.

Post a comment

In order to encourage respectful and thoughtful discussion, commenting on stories is available to those who are registered users. If you are already a registered user and the commenting form is not below, you need to log in. If you are not registered, you can do so here.

Please make sure your comments are truthful, on-topic and do not disrespect another poster. Don't be snarky or belittling. All postings are subject to our TERMS OF USE, and may be deleted if deemed inappropriate by our staff.

See our announcement about requiring registration for commenting.