Town Square

Post a New Topic

Editorial: Universal district-based elections do not make sense here

Original post made on May 27, 2019

Many municipalities in the Tri-Valley are being forced to adopt district-based elections or risk being sued, which could result in costs of millions of dollars from a likely unwinnable case.

Read the full story here Web Link posted Sunday, May 26, 2019, 5:45 PM

Comments (8)

10 people like this
Posted by Laura
a resident of Monte Vista High School
on May 27, 2019 at 1:53 pm

I agree 100%, but didn’t see that there was anything we could do as voting citizens to stop this change. Some things are better left as is. I don’t like the idea whatsoever that I can’t vote for all members on the SRVUSD School Board now, especially since what each of them does has an impact on my child and all children attending the SRVUSD schools, independent of whether we live in San Ramon, Danville, or unincorporated Danville, Blackhawk or Alamo. It’s a very unfortunate election change and I believe it will negatively affect our community and our top-rated school district.

Posted by Seth
a resident of Danville

on May 27, 2019 at 5:50 pm

Remember me?
Forgot Password?
Due to violations of our Terms of Use, comments from this poster are only visible to registered users who are logged in. Use the links at the top of the page to Register or Login.

13 people like this
Posted by Scott J Rafferty
a resident of Walnut Creek
on May 28, 2019 at 12:24 pm

Scott J Rafferty is a registered user.

Neighborhood elections empower voters and strengthen government. By contrast, at-large elections have prevented voters from the eastern half of the city from ever having elected a neighbor to city council, the school board, the fire district, or DSRSD. Smaller constituencies also lower the costs of campaigning, enabling grass-roots candidates to make elections more competitive. It is understandable that some incumbents, and those who support them, favor the system that brought them to power, but every neighborhood should have equal electoral influence. And every voter in San Ramon Valley benefits from more competitive elections.

The article's fear that districted officials will only serve the needs of their "vocal neighborhood" ignores history and logic. Representative democracy works. We elect state and federal legislators from single member constituencies so that they bring an understanding of our local values and conditions, but they always serve the entire state and nation. As Madison predicted, individually electing representatives allowed America to avoid the divisive factions and instability that had been typical of parliaments elected at large.

However, a century ago, many local jurisdictions began electing at-large to exclude ethic neighborhoods from electing candidates of their choice. This winner-take-all system had become the norm in Northern California when San Ramon was incorporated, but most cities of similar size have since returned to district elections. The high costs of campaigning in SRVUSD (one of the biggest at-large districts in the state) has meant that no incumbent (elected or appointed) has been successfully challenged in 25 years. When SRVUSD had a rare vacancy, 8 of the 18 applicants were from Dougherty Valley (all Asian) and none even received an interview.

In San Ramon Valley, federal law requires single-member districts because there is a geographical area in which a majority of voters are Asian. Winner-take-all deprives voters from this area (white and Asian) of influence in elections that is equal to that of voters in the rest of the jurisdiction. All elected officials for all four jurisdictions, even Sabina Zafar, live in areas that are not majority Asian.

The Voting Rights Act is all about voters, not incumbents and candidates or the color of their skin. The election of Sabina Zafar did not "correct" this problem. She does not live east of Dougherty Road. That large area needs to be able to choose its preferred candidate, who may or may not be Asian.

Finally, districting lowers election costs by about 50%. The editorial is wrong to suggest that it cost $60,000 to conduct an all-mail special election in Dublin USD, because the trustee area only has 5000 voters. Oddly, the editors have no problem with the very high costs of having everyone vote for every candidate every two years, even though this winner-take-all system means that much of the Valley never gets to elect any candidate of its choice.

2 people like this
Posted by Roz Rogoff
a resident of San Ramon
on May 30, 2019 at 8:18 am

I live in Sunny Glen, which is a retirement area. While it is possible for parents 55 years old and up to have young children or teens, most residents here do not have school age children living with them. So now Sunny Glen will have more influence electing a member of the School Board, which seems contrary to the goal of providing ethnic diversity on the Board.

Posted by Name hidden
a resident of Danville

on May 30, 2019 at 9:31 am

Due to repeated violations of our Terms of Use, comments from this poster are automatically removed. Why?

11 people like this
Posted by The Dude
a resident of San Ramon
on Jun 10, 2019 at 7:02 pm

Mr. Rafferty,
You're not very familiar with the geography of San Ramon, are you? Thanks for coming in to save us from ourselves.

Posted by Name hidden
a resident of Danville

on Jun 10, 2019 at 10:21 pm

Due to repeated violations of our Terms of Use, comments from this poster are automatically removed. Why?

Posted by Name hidden
a resident of Danville

on Jun 10, 2019 at 10:21 pm

Due to repeated violations of our Terms of Use, comments from this poster are automatically removed. Why?

Sorry, but further commenting on this topic has been closed.

All your news. All in one place. Every day.

Premarital, Women Over 50 Do Get Married
By Chandrama Anderson | 0 comments | 1,942 views

10x Genomics goes public today
By Tim Hunt | 0 comments | 940 views

How Your Email Impacts College Admission Results!
By Elizabeth LaScala | 0 comments | 652 views

Art Inside-Out, Body of Work (Literally)
By John A. Barry and Bill Carmel | 2 comments | 389 views


Nominations due by Sept. 16 and Pleasanton Weekly are once again putting out a call for nominations and sponsorships for the annual Tri-Valley Heroes awards - our salute to the community members dedicated to bettering the Tri-Valley and the lives of its residents.

Nomination form